University of Illinois College of Law University of Illinois College of Law
prospective current faculty academics library alumni careers


 

Moose Turd Pie

Cribbet This first originated when I was speaking as a young professor at the Alpha Delta house on the campus. It was for a fraternity affair, and the fraternity members had stuck a cigarette in the mouth of the moose which was hanging over the fireplace. That reminded me of this story which I had heard at Fort Benning, Georgia when I was on the staff at the school before I went over-seas. And it related to a group of people, who, after World War I, decided that they would go to Alaska to homestead and to look for gold.

They got pretty well organized, each individual had his own job to perform, but they had one little man who didn't have anything yet to do, and they had no cook. So they appointed him as the cook. But he said, "Well, I will accept on one condition, and that condition is if anybody ever complains about my cooking, then they have to be the chef."

"A lawyer can relate almost anything to something else if you give him enough time."

Well, the cooking was pretty bad, and it got worse, but nobody complained. And finally, after a long time, he decided to fix things for sure, so he went out on the frozen tundra of the North, and gathered up a great pile of moose defecation. He brought it back and baked it into a gorgeous looking pie with a great crust all covered with butter, something that smelled very savory on the outside.

One of the big lumber jacks came in, dug his elbows onto the table and took a great big piece of pie, spit it clear across the table and said, "My God! Moose turd pie! But good, but good."

I related that, of course a lawyer could relate almost anything to something else if you give him enough time, but I related that to perhaps law school itself. There are times when you may think that legal education bears some similarity with moose turd pie — but good, but good — because in the long run, it will pay heavy dividends.

"There are times when you may think that legal education bears some similarity with moose turd pie — but good, but good — because in the long run, it will pay heavy dividends."

That particular story I told for the first time after I came back from the University of Michigan. I had taught there for the full year, came very close to staying on the faculty at the University of Michigan, but returned to Illinois. And in making some speeches to alumni, one of the questions I was always asked was how did this relate to the University of Illinois? And I said well it's still moose at Michigan, just as it is at Illinois.

Incidentally, one of you, who might be listening to me, did me the honor on one occasion when I was at Professor Scholl's house celebrating a birthday party, of organizing a group of students to show up bringing with them a moose turd pie. Literally baked, covered with meringue, with candles on top and presented it to me. It was synthetic, a true phony, because they had used cow rather than moose, but otherwise, it worked out rather well.