University of Illinois College of Law University of Illinois College of Law
prospective current faculty academics library alumni careers


 

Big Picture Story

What really happened in this particular story, which I first told at the end of World War II, dealt with a portion of my military experiences. During the closing days of World War II in Europe, I was the senior aide-decamp to Lieutenant General Troy Middleton. He was the Senior Core Commander under General George Patton and was really one of the great leaders of World War II. Because I was Middleton's aide, I got to go with him to a lot of high level conferences and got to know many of the major leaders of World War II rather well. Met Eisenhower, saw a lot of Bradley, and a great deal of General Patton, one of the more colorful figures of World War II as you will recall.

Patton had returned from a meeting at SHAFE Headquarters outside Paris, and had been talking to Beetle Smith, who was the Chief-of- Staff for General Eisenhower. Smith did not like Patton, and the feeling was mutual. They had both been full Colonels at Fort Myer in Virginia years before but Patton had been the Senior in Command. They were both now four star generals and Patton thought Smith should call him General. Instead what Smith did was to rather patronize Patton, lean over and pat him on the back and say, "That's alright Georgie," a name which Patton truly hated.

At any rate, Patton, as he was telling this story, was arguing for a swift, rapier-like thrust into the heart of Germany to end the war. Smith said, "Well, the trouble with you Georgie, you just don't understand the 'Big Picture.' We had to send all the supplies and troops to General Montgomery in the North because that's where we were making our principal thrust."

"I'm sure that all of you who may remember that story, now have a better idea of the 'Big Picture' a you had all those years ago."

As Patton was telling this in Luxembourg City to his assembled core commanders, at his feet was an English bulldog named Willie. Willie was one of the ugliest beasts known to man, he looked more like a pig than a dog, and he was easily bored and whenever he was bored, he would yawn. The unfortunate beast chose that particular moment to yawn, Patton launched a kick at him that almost carried him off his feet and he said, "Laugh, laugh, you little son-of-a-bitch, you don't understand the 'Big Picture' either."

Now, the truth of the matter is, that I doubt if Willie understood the Big Picture, I'm pretty sure that General Patton did not, and as near as I can tell, most days since World War II no one did. Perhaps now, as we begin to settle the Cold War and move into an era of greater cooperation between the super powers, we will get a better glimpse of that 'Big Picture.'

Well the importance of the story was when I was Dean, I told it to countless students at the time of orientation, I usually told it to my class, and I concluded by pointing out that although Patton may not have known the 'Big Picture,' maybe no one did, that it was very important that they understand the 'Big Picture' - that is the big picture of law, and how the pieces of the jigsaw puzzle fit together to form the grand mosaic that is the law. No one individual can give you that big picture of the law, but if you work hard and study the cases and the materials, you can put them together and form your own view of the 'Big Picture,' and that is a part of what you will take with you when you leave the halls of ivy and go out into practice in your various spheres of influence.

I'm sure that all of you who may remember that story, now have a better idea of the Big Picture' than you had all those years ago.